
Essay 2: Synthesis and Research on Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein and Karel Capek’s Rossum’s Universal Robots
Length: Approximately 2000 words (6-8 pages double-spaced, 1” margins, 12 pt TNR font)
Abstract due: Feb. 25
Draft Workshop: March 4 (Minimum 3 full pages)
Final Project due: March 11 in class
Mary Shelley’s novel and Karel Capek’s drama have both played vital roles in the history of technology and literature. They have been commercially and critically successful texts, and they have inspired performances and adaptations into various media. Arguably, much seems to have changed in the world of technology and our relationships with it since 1818 and 1920: we have smart phones, laptops, iPods, H1N1 and H1N1 vaccines, GPS, Dolly the cloned sheep, and biogenetically modified foods. Still, these texts remain relevant to us today as evinced by their inclusion in university courses as well as references in popular culture (RUR provided the name of the corporation in the recent Joss Whedon TV show Dollhouse). In this essay, you will put these two texts into conversation with each other in order to make a contentious thesis argument on what they say about the relationships linking humans and technology.
Here are the objectives of this essay-writing assignment:
You are expected to write a 6-8 page essay that focuses primarily on articulating a coherent and compelling analytical interpretation that reads the two texts together and devotes equal time/pages to both.
Your essay must include sustained analyses of formal aspects of the texts. Also, be sure you make use of your attention to form—don’t just drop a term/concept and consider it sufficient.
Your essay must include analyses of the texts’ content. You are expected to complete this course having achieved the ability to read literary texts with both content and form in mind and to be able to put these elements of the text into conversation with each other.
Your essay must include references to two scholarly critiques of the texts. To include one of each is ideal, but because critiques of Capek’s drama are less common, you may use two critiques of Frankenstein. Don’t worry: we will discuss source research and selection in class.
Your essay must make at least one reference to the film Blade Runner. Do not simply mention the film, but be sure you refer to it to help illustrate a point you are making about the other two texts.
Your essay must be thesis-driven and evidence-based. In other words, a successful essay will have a clear argument that is appropriate for the scope of a 6-8 page essay, and it will use direct textual evidence to develop the support for this thesis. Your essay must demonstrate close reading skills in its treatment of the textual evidence. To choose appropriate, convincing evidence, make sure each piece of text relates to your thesis and to the other pieces of evidence used in the essay. Remember that sometimes “less is more” when it comes to how much you quote. It’s better to analyze fully a selection of key moments in texts rather than include a large catalog of moments that are incompletely addressed.
And a successful essay will employ MLA citation practices and will be thoroughly proofread and edited. (The Learning Skills Center in Dutton Hall can help you with grammar/style and other issues, especially if you plan ahead to use their resources.)
Abstract:
You should submit a one-page abstract to me on February 25th. This is a proposal for your essay, and it should detail your position and plan for the argument. I will hand out an abstract form for you to use in completing this task.
Peer Workshop:
Reminder—as stated in the syllabus, the workshop on March 4th is required. Failure to attend or to attend without a substantial draft in hand will result in a 1/3 grade reduction on the final essay.
Checklist:
When you turn in the essay to me on March 15th, make sure it includes the following:
o The final version
o The draft workshop version with comment sheets
o The abstract
o The revision memo
The following are some possible directions you could take to develop a good thesis, but this is not an exhaustive list. Feel free to consult with me as you develop your thesis idea.
Definitions of what it means to “Be Human”
Sex and/or Gender roles in the texts
Technology and Studies
Technology and Work
Technophobia, Technophilia, or combinations of these